Can home equity loans help another group feeling the pinch?

Imagine the shock reading about yet another group being left behind, this time, those in the upper half of the the wealth pyramid below the top 10 percent?  As is my predilection, familiar to my devoted reader, I immediately focused on the impact of housing.

Source: Bloomberg Business

The above chart shows that, even after a decade of de-levering and then re-levering with the tailwind of an extended run-up of home prices, the share of housing debt as a portion of total indebtedness has dropped substantially.  The author then serves up a chart on rising debt service costs to back up his contention about households shifting to higher interest rate debt categories.

Can Home Equity Loans Help? 

Source: Black Knight February 2019 Mortgage Monitor

Abundantly clear from the above chart is that consumers are currently sitting on nearly 2.2x more tappable equity than at the end of the recession, despite multiple first mortgage refinance waves that have soaked up significant excess home equity.

Moreover, both HELOC balances and limits have come down in during the period in question while credit card balances and limits have risen.

Finally, when debt share by product is compared between two age cohorts (30-49 vs. 50-69), one notices a material difference in HELOC adoption.  One also sees that there could be economic value in substituting HELOCs for higher cost credit card debt in both cohorts.

Any Conclusions?

No slam dunks here, but there's evidence that, beneath the headlines around tappable home equity, there's clear indication of changing consumer behaviors, and not necessarily for the better.  There's also an opportunity for consumers to save substantially by moving from higher cost credit card debt to some form of secured home equity loans.